The Role of the Church in Judgment

The church is called not only to be a place of worship but also a body that lovingly judges and discerns among its members. This judgment is not about eternal salvation — that is God’s domain (James 4:12) — but about addressing actions that either align with or oppose God’s standards. In a culture where tolerance has been redefined to mean full acceptance rather than respectful disagreement, biblical judgment often feels controversial. However, Scripture consistently calls the church to judge actions within its body for the sake of sanctification (1 Corinthians 5:12-13).

The Church’s Responsibility to Judge Sin

In 1 Corinthians 5:1-13, Paul confronts a shocking case of immorality within the Corinthian church. A man was engaged in an ongoing, unrepentant sexual relationship with his father’s wife. Rather than grieving over this sin, the church was proud. Paul exhorts them to remove the unrepentant individual from their fellowship. This act of discipline was not motivated by self-righteousness, but by a desire to preserve the purity of the church and to lead the sinner back to repentance (1 Corinthians 5:2, 5).

Sin is described as yeast that permeates the entire batch of dough (1 Corinthians 5:6). Left unchecked, sin spreads and corrupts the entire body. Therefore, dealing with sin decisively protects the holiness of the church and upholds its testimony before the world.

Sanctifying the Believer Through Judgment

The goal of church discipline is restoration, not condemnation. By removing the unrepentant sinner from fellowship, the church forces the individual to experience the weight of separation from the body and the blessings it provides — love, accountability, encouragement, and support. The prayer is that through this loss, the believer would recognize the destructiveness of sin, repent, and ultimately be saved on the day of the Lord (1 Corinthians 5:5).

This process mirrors the reality that sin is like sugar-coated poison: it may taste sweet initially, but it leads to death. Loving discipline acts as a wake-up call, exposing sin’s true nature and leading the sinner back to Christ.

Judgment Is for the Church, Not the World

Paul makes a clear distinction between judging those inside the church and those outside. Believers are called to judge fellow believers who claim the name of Christ but live in unrepentant sin. However, Christians are not called to judge the world (1 Corinthians 5:9-13). Outsiders act according to their nature, and judgment belongs to God alone. The church’s mission toward the world is to share the gospel, not to enforce Christian standards on those who do not know Christ.

This distinction is critical in a culture where many identify as Christians without living according to biblical truth. The standard is applied not based on perfect knowledge of salvation but on the individual’s profession of faith and lifestyle.

The Importance of Humility in Judgment

Judgment must always be approached with humility and self-awareness. Jesus teaches that before addressing the speck in a brother’s eye, one must first remove the plank from one’s own (Matthew 7:1-5). God’s primary call is for believers to examine themselves, pursuing personal holiness with earnestness. Only from a place of humility and love should they help others confront sin.

Critical spirits must be avoided. Loving conversations and gentle questions often open the door for correction more effectively than harsh rebukes. Conversations are not synonymous with condemnation; they are opportunities to seek understanding and point others to the truth of God’s Word (Galatians 6:1).

Conflict Resolution in the Church

Where judgment exists, conflict is inevitable. However, Scripture provides a path for resolving conflict among believers. Matthew 18:15-17 outlines the process: address the issue privately first, involve others if necessary, and bring it before the church as a last resort. Romans 12:18 reminds believers that, as much as it depends on them, they should live at peace with everyone.

Unity within the church is essential. Christians are called to forgive as they have been forgiven (Colossians 3:13) and to maintain the bond of peace through love and humility. Handling conflict biblically reflects the love of Christ and strengthens the witness of the church.

The Church: A Gift for Growth

The church is a divine gift meant for mutual growth and sanctification. Believers are interconnected; the actions of one affect the whole body (Ephesians 4:16). In loving judgment, the church helps individuals see sin clearly, turn back to God, and grow in holiness. This sanctifying work builds up the church into the spotless bride Christ desires (Ephesians 5:25-27).

Far from being oppressive or harsh, biblical judgment within the church is a profound act of love and grace. It calls sinners back to life, preserves the witness of the church, and glorifies God.

---